Free Shipping on any order over $100!

First time buyer? Use code HI2GREYCAT10 at checkout to receive 10% off your first order!

Free local delivery to Raleigh-Durham-Chapel Hill, NC!

Use code HI2GREYCAT10 for 10% off your first order.

Cart 0

Sorry, looks like we don't have enough of this product.

Is this a gift?
Add order notes
Subtotal Free
View cart
Shipping, taxes, and discount codes are calculated at checkout
Person wearing a helmet and balaclava with a yellow background

Protomartyr - Consolation E.P.

Vinyl, 12", 45 RPM, EP, Limited Edition, Yellow & White Starburst

Grief hangs heavy over Consolation, but it never settles into stillness.

Released in 2018, this EP finds Protomartyr channeling loss into something restrained and deliberate. It’s quieter than much of their catalog, but the tension remains, just pulled inward rather than pushed out.

The arrangements are sparse and measured. Guitars move in slow, deliberate lines, bass sits low and steady, and the rhythms feel almost suspended at times. There’s a subtle shift in tone across the EP, with moments of warmth and reflection breaking through the band’s usual austerity. Joe Casey’s vocals remain central, delivering lines with a weary, contemplative weight.

Consolation works as a focused, intimate release. It captures Protomartyr stepping back just enough to let emotion surface in a different way, quieter, but no less impactful.

A1 Wait 2:10
A2 Same Face In A Different Mirror 2:48

B1 Wheel Of Fortune 5:16
B2 You Always Win 3:57

Sleeve Condition: Very Good + (VG+)
Vinyl Condition: Near Mint (NM)

Photos available upon request. Please see our Used FAQ below for more information on our grading system.

Protomartyr - Consolation E.P.

$18.00

Greycat Used Records

How we grade vinyl

All used vinyl are fully tested to ensure accuracy. We follow the Goldmine standard and grade conservatively.

Here’s how we rate:

  • Mint (M): Perfect, sealed, or unplayed.
  • Near Mint (NM): Looks and plays like new with minimal signs of handling.
  • Very Good+ (VG+): A few light cosmetic marks or faint surface noise.
  • Very Good (VG): Noticeable wear and some background noise, but no skips or major flaws.
  • Good (G): Heavier wear and noise, but still listenable.
  • Fair (F): Heavily worn or noisy—priced accordingly and sold as-is.

Can I return a used vinyl purchase?

All used vinyl sales are final.

If you have questions about condition, feel free to reach out before ordering. If you want to feel more confident before purchasing, ask us for photos of the sleeve or vinyl. We're more than happy to provide those!


With Greycat Records You Get:

Fast Shipping

You know what sucks? Ordering new vinyl and seeing that it's still "being prepared" days later.

When you order with us, your vinyl will ship out within 24 hours. We'll reach out to if you if there are any delays beyond that.

Order Tracking

As soon as your order is on its way, you'll receive tracking to monitor its journey from Greycat HQ to your doorstep.

You'll always know where your package is, giving you peace of mind and the power to plan accordingly.

Customer Service

If you have any questions, concerns, or just want to say hello, don't hesitate to get in touch with us through our contact page or emailing us at hello@greycatrecords.com.

We'll be more than happy to help with any inquiries or assistance you may need. Your satisfaction is our priority.